0x55aa
← Back to Blog

Monolith vs Microservices: When NOT to Split Your App (Yes, Really!) 🏗️💥

•16 min read
architecturemicroservicesmonolithscalabilitysystem-design

Monolith vs Microservices: When NOT to Split Your App (Yes, Really!) 🏗️💥

Real confession: In 2018, I convinced my team to split our perfectly fine monolith into 12 microservices. Why? Because that's what all the cool tech companies were doing! Netflix did it. Uber did it. We should too, right?

6 months later:

  • Development time: 2x slower
  • Bugs: 3x more
  • Infrastructure cost: 4x higher
  • Complexity: ♾️
  • My team's morale: 📉📉📉

My CTO: "Can we... just go back to the monolith?"

Me, realizing I'd been seduced by hype: "Yes. Yes we can." 😭

Welcome to the unpopular truth: Microservices aren't always the answer. In fact, for most teams, they're the WRONG answer!

The Monolith vs Microservices Reality Check 🤔

Think of it like housing:

Monolith = One big house:

┌──────────────────────────┐
│  Living Room (Frontend)  │
│  Kitchen (API Logic)     │
│  Bedroom (Database)      │
│  Bathroom (Auth)         │
└──────────────────────────┘

One building, everything connected
Easy to navigate, simple to maintain

Microservices = Apartment complex:

Building A (Auth Service)     🏢
Building B (User Service)     🏢
Building C (Product Service)  🏢
Building D (Order Service)    🏢
Building E (Payment Service)  🏢
Building F (Email Service)    🏢

6 buildings, complex routing between them
Need a map, dedicated maintenance crew

Translation: Monolith = Everything in one codebase. Microservices = Split into separate services. Both have trade-offs!

The Great Microservices Migration Disaster 💀

When I was a Technical Lead at my e-commerce company, I read all the Medium articles about microservices. They made it sound so easy! "Just split your app into services!" they said. "It'll scale better!" they said.

What I thought would happen:

// Before: Monolith (supposedly bad)
app.post('/checkout', async (req, res) => {
    const order = await createOrder(req.body);
    const payment = await processPayment(order);
    const email = await sendConfirmation(order);
    res.json({ success: true, orderId: order.id });
    // Works perfectly, 200ms response time
});

// After: Microservices (supposedly better!)
// Should be faster and more scalable! 🚀

What ACTUALLY happened:

// After: Microservices (the nightmare)
app.post('/checkout', async (req, res) => {
    try {
        // Call 5 different services
        const order = await fetch('http://order-service/create', {
            method: 'POST',
            body: JSON.stringify(req.body)
        });

        const payment = await fetch('http://payment-service/charge', {
            method: 'POST',
            body: JSON.stringify({ orderId: order.id, amount: order.total })
        });

        const inventory = await fetch('http://inventory-service/decrement', {
            method: 'POST',
            body: JSON.stringify({ items: order.items })
        });

        const email = await fetch('http://email-service/send', {
            method: 'POST',
            body: JSON.stringify({ orderId: order.id, email: req.user.email })
        });

        const analytics = await fetch('http://analytics-service/track', {
            method: 'POST',
            body: JSON.stringify({ event: 'checkout', orderId: order.id })
        });

        res.json({ success: true, orderId: order.id });

    } catch (error) {
        // Which service failed? Who knows! 🤷
        // How to rollback? Good luck!
        // Logs scattered across 5 services!
        res.status(500).json({ error: 'Something broke somewhere' });
    }
});

// Response time: 200ms → 1.5s (7x slower!)
// Error rate: 0.1% → 5% (50x worse!)
// Debugging time: 10 min → 3 hours
// My sanity: GONE 😱

The fallout:

  • Network calls: 1 → 5 (more points of failure!)
  • Latency: 200ms → 1.5s (network overhead)
  • Distributed transactions: Nightmare (how to rollback partial failures?)
  • Debugging: Logs scattered across 5 services
  • Development: Need to run 5+ services locally
  • Testing: Integration tests became a hellscape
  • Cost: $500/month → $2000/month (separate infrastructure for each service)

A scalability lesson that cost us: We were handling 10,000 users. The monolith was working FINE. We didn't need microservices - we needed better caching!

When Microservices ACTUALLY Make Sense ✅

Don't get me wrong - microservices can be amazing! But ONLY when you actually need them:

Reason #1: You Have 100+ Developers

The problem with monoliths at scale:

// 100 developers touching the same codebase
Team A: Adds feature to auth module
Team B: Refactors auth module
Team C: Fixes bug in auth module
Team D: Updates auth tests

// Merge conflicts: EVERYWHERE! 💥
// Deploy coordination: NIGHTMARE
// Code ownership: IMPOSSIBLE

Microservices solution:

Auth Service    → Team A (5 devs)
User Service    → Team B (5 devs)
Product Service → Team C (8 devs)
Order Service   → Team D (6 devs)

// Each team owns their service
// Independent deploys
// Clear boundaries

My rule: < 10 developers? Stick with monolith. 50+ developers? Consider microservices. 100+ developers? You probably need microservices.

Reason #2: Different Scaling Requirements

Real scenario from our e-commerce backend:

// Product catalog: 10 requests/sec (light load)
// User service: 50 requests/sec (medium load)
// Search service: 500 requests/sec (heavy load!)
// Image processing: CPU-intensive (needs GPU!)

// In a monolith: Scale EVERYTHING together (waste!)
// With microservices: Scale each service independently

The math:

Monolith (scaling together):
- 10 servers × $50/month = $500/month
- 90% of capacity wasted on light services

Microservices (scaling independently):
- Product catalog: 1 server × $50 = $50
- User service: 2 servers × $50 = $100
- Search service: 5 servers × $50 = $250
- Image processing: 2 GPU servers × $200 = $400
Total: $800/month

More expensive, but RIGHT resources for each service!

When I use this: When different parts of the app have WILDLY different resource needs!

Reason #3: Different Technology Requirements

Real use case:

// Main app: Node.js (API logic)
// ML recommendations: Python (TensorFlow)
// Real-time analytics: Go (performance)
// Legacy integration: Java (enterprise libs)

// Monolith: Pick ONE language, compromise everywhere
// Microservices: Best tool for each job!

But honestly? This is RARELY a good reason. Can you really not solve your problem in one language? 🤔

Reason #4: Team Independence is Critical

The dream scenario:

// E-commerce platform
Payment Team → Owns entire payment flow
Can deploy 5x/day without coordinating with anyone
Uses Stripe? PayPal? Square? They decide!
Tech stack? They choose!

// This independence is POWERFUL!
// But only if you have dedicated teams!

Reality check: If you're a 5-person startup, you ARE all the teams. Microservices just slow you down!

When to Absolutely STAY with a Monolith 🚫

Scenario #1: You're a Startup (< 2 Years Old)

The startup reality:

// Your priorities:
1. Ship features FAST
2. Validate product-market fit
3. Pivot when needed
4. Survive on limited budget

// Microservices add:
- 3x development time (service setup, networking, deployment)
- 4x infrastructure cost (separate servers, load balancers, service mesh)
- 10x complexity (distributed debugging, orchestration)

// Result: You run out of money before finding product-market fit! 💸

My startup advice: Start with a monolith. Split later IF you survive AND if you need to!

Success story: Shopify ran on a monolith until they had 100+ engineers and millions of merchants. They're doing fine! 🛍️

Scenario #2: Your Team is < 10 People

The communication overhead:

// With monolith (5 developers):
Communication channels: 10 (manageable!)

// With microservices (5 developers, 8 services):
- Who owns which service? 🤷
- Need to coordinate changes across services
- Everyone needs to understand 8 codebases!
- More time in meetings than coding!

// Conway's Law: Systems mirror communication structure
// Small team + microservices = DISASTER

When designing our e-commerce backend, I learned: Microservices need dedicated teams per service. One developer maintaining 3 services? Recipe for burnout!

Scenario #3: No Distributed Systems Experience

The hidden complexity:

// Problems you WILL face with microservices:
❌ Distributed transactions (how to rollback?)
❌ Network failures (what if service is down?)
❌ Eventual consistency (data sync issues)
❌ Service discovery (how services find each other)
❌ API versioning (breaking changes)
❌ Distributed tracing (debugging nightmares)
❌ Circuit breakers (prevent cascading failures)
❌ Bulkheads (resource isolation)
❌ Load balancing (distribute traffic)
❌ Message queues (async communication)

// Each of these is a PhD-level topic!
// Your team ready for this? 😰

My experience: If your team hasn't dealt with distributed systems, microservices will CRUSH you. Start simple!

Scenario #4: Your Traffic is Low

The brutal math:

// Your app handles:
100 requests/minute = 6,000 requests/hour

// Monolith on $50/month server:
- Can handle 10,000 requests/min easily
- 99.5% idle capacity
- Works perfectly!

// Microservices (8 services × $50/month):
- $400/month infrastructure
- 8x the maintenance burden
- No actual performance benefit!

// You're paying 8x more for NOTHING!

The rule: If one server can handle your load, you don't need microservices! Use caching and optimization first!

Scenario #5: You Need to Move Fast

Feature development comparison:

// Adding "User can upload profile photo"

// Monolith (1 day):
1. Add image upload endpoint (30 min)
2. Store image path in database (15 min)
3. Update user profile page (2 hours)
4. Write tests (2 hours)
5. Deploy (10 min)
Done! ✅

// Microservices (1 week):
1. Which service handles this? User service? Image service? New service?
2. Design API contract between services (1 day)
3. Update User service API (4 hours)
4. Update Image service (4 hours)
5. Update Frontend to call both services (4 hours)
6. Handle failure scenarios (2 days)
7. Write integration tests (1 day)
8. Deploy 3 services in correct order (1 hour)
9. Fix production bugs from missed edge cases (4 hours)
Done! 😭

// Same feature, 7x longer!

As a Technical Lead, I've learned: If speed matters more than scale, monolith wins EVERY TIME!

The Modular Monolith: The Best of Both Worlds? 🎯

Plot twist: You can get SOME benefits of microservices without the pain!

The concept:

// Modular Monolith
// One codebase, clear module boundaries

src/
  ├── modules/
  │   ├── auth/
  │   │   ├── auth.service.js
  │   │   ├── auth.controller.js
  │   │   └── auth.model.js
  │   ├── users/
  │   │   ├── users.service.js
  │   │   ├── users.controller.js
  │   │   └── users.model.js
  │   ├── products/
  │   │   ├── products.service.js
  │   │   ├── products.controller.js
  │   │   └── products.model.js
  │   └── orders/
  │       ├── orders.service.js
  │       ├── orders.controller.js
  │       └── orders.model.js
  └── shared/
      ├── database.js
      └── utils.js

// Rules:
// ✅ Modules can't import from other modules directly
// ✅ Communication through defined interfaces
// ✅ Each module could become a microservice later!

Benefits:

  • ✅ Fast development (no network calls!)
  • ✅ Easy debugging (single process!)
  • ✅ Clear boundaries (can extract later if needed!)
  • ✅ Shared database (no distributed transactions!)
  • ✅ Low cost (one server!)

When I use modular monoliths: For 80% of projects! It's the sweet spot between chaos and over-engineering!

The Migration Path: Monolith → Microservices (When You Actually Need It) 🛤️

If you MUST go to microservices, do it gradually:

Step 1: Start with Strangler Pattern

// Don't rewrite everything at once!
// Extract ONE service at a time

// Week 1: Extract email service (least risky)
Monolith → handles most logic
Email Service → just sends emails

// Week 4: Extract payment service
Monolith → handles orders, products, users
Email Service → emails
Payment Service → payments

// Week 8: Extract product catalog
Monolith → handles orders, users
Email Service → emails
Payment Service → payments
Product Service → products

// 6 months later: Fully distributed (if you still need it!)

Why this works: You learn distributed systems gradually. If it fails, easy to rollback!

Step 2: Database Per Service (Later!)

// Start: Shared database
All services → Single PostgreSQL database

// Problem: Can still cause tight coupling
// But MUCH easier than distributed database from day 1!

// Later: Split databases
Email Service → Redis (session storage)
Payment Service → PostgreSQL (transactions)
Product Service → MongoDB (flexible schema)
Analytics Service → ClickHouse (time-series)

// Only when you actually need different databases!

A lesson I learned the hard way: Don't split the database until services are stable! Distributed transactions are HELL!

Step 3: Add Infrastructure Gradually

// Week 1: Direct HTTP calls
Service A → HTTP → Service B
// Simple, easy to debug

// Week 4: Add load balancer
Service A → Load Balancer → Service B
// Better reliability

// Week 8: Add message queue
Service A → RabbitMQ → Service B
// Async communication, better resilience

// Week 12: Add service mesh
Service A → Istio → Service B
// Advanced features (tracing, circuit breakers, retries)

// Build complexity as you need it, not before!

The Real Cost of Microservices (Nobody Talks About) 💸

Beyond infrastructure:

// Monolith monthly cost:
$50   - EC2 instance
$20   - Database
$10   - Monitoring
$5    - CI/CD
────────────
$85 TOTAL

// Microservices monthly cost (8 services):
$400  - 8 EC2 instances ($50 each)
$150  - 3 Databases (separate per service)
$100  - Load balancers ($50 each, need 2 for HA)
$80   - Service mesh (Istio control plane)
$50   - Message queue (RabbitMQ/Kafka)
$60   - Monitoring (per-service metrics)
$40   - CI/CD (8 pipelines)
$30   - Log aggregation
$20   - Service discovery
────────────
$930 TOTAL (11x more expensive!)

// Hidden costs:
Developer time: 2-3x slower development
DevOps time: 4x more infrastructure to manage
Learning curve: 6 months to become productive
Mental health: PRICELESS 😅

When architecting on AWS, I learned: Start cheap (monolith), scale smart (caching + CDN), split only when necessary!

Decision Framework: Should I Use Microservices? 🤔

Ask yourself these questions:

// Question 1: Team size?
< 10 people → Monolith! ✅
10-50 people → Modular Monolith! ✅
50-100 people → Consider microservices 🤔
100+ people → Probably microservices ✅

// Question 2: Traffic?
< 100 requests/min → Monolith! ✅
100-1000 requests/min → Probably monolith ✅
1000-10,000 requests/min → Modular monolith or microservices 🤔
10,000+ requests/min → Microservices make sense ✅

// Question 3: Distributed systems experience?
None → MONOLITH! ✅
Some → Modular monolith, then migrate ✅
Expert → You can handle microservices ✅

// Question 4: Do different parts need different scaling?
No → Monolith! ✅
A little → Vertical scaling + caching ✅
Drastically → Microservices make sense ✅

// Question 5: How fast do you need to ship?
ASAP (startup) → Monolith! ✅
Fast (scale-up) → Modular monolith ✅
Measured (enterprise) → Can consider microservices 🤔

// Question 6: Budget?
Tight → Monolith! ✅
Comfortable → Monolith still! ✅
Unlimited → Microservices if it helps ✅

My scoring system:

  • All "Monolith!" answers → STAY MONOLITH
  • Mix of answers → Start with Modular Monolith
  • All "Microservices" answers → You're probably Amazon, you don't need my advice! 😄

Common Microservices Myths (Debunked!) 🔥

Myth #1: "Microservices are more scalable"

Truth: Monoliths can scale HORIZONTALLY too!

// Monolith horizontal scaling:
Load Balancer → [Instance 1, Instance 2, Instance 3, ...]
Same code on multiple servers!

// Handles 100,000 requests/min easily!
// Stack Overflow runs on a monolith and handles billions of requests!

Myth #2: "Microservices enable faster deployment"

Truth: Only if you have multiple teams!

// 5-person team:
Monolith deploy: 10 minutes
Microservices deploy: 45 minutes (8 services × 5-10 min each)

// Slower, not faster! 🐌

Myth #3: "Microservices reduce bugs"

Truth: Distributed systems ADD complexity!

// New failure modes:
❌ Network failures
❌ Service discovery issues
❌ Timeout cascades
❌ Distributed transaction rollbacks
❌ Data consistency issues
❌ Partial failures

// Bugs don't disappear - they multiply! 🐛🐛🐛

Myth #4: "Microservices are modern, monoliths are legacy"

Truth: Architecture should match your needs!

// "Modern" companies on monoliths:
- Shopify (PHP monolith)
- Stack Overflow (.NET monolith)
- Basecamp (Ruby monolith)

// They're doing JUST FINE! 💪

The Bottom Line 💡

Microservices are a tool, not a goal!

The essentials:

  1. Start with a monolith - Simple, fast, cheap
  2. Keep modules separate - Prepare for future extraction
  3. Scale with caching first - Often solves 90% of performance issues
  4. Split only when necessary - Real pain, not hype
  5. Migrate gradually - Strangler pattern, not big bang

The truth about microservices:

They're not "better" - they're DIFFERENT! You're trading simplicity for scalability, speed for independence, low cost for flexibility!

When designing our e-commerce backend, I learned this the hard way: The best architecture is the simplest one that meets your needs. Microservices might be cool, but they're not worth the pain unless you genuinely need them! 🎯

You don't need to be Netflix to succeed! Start simple, measure, scale when you actually need it! 🚀

Your Action Plan (Start Simple!) ✅

This week:

  1. Audit your current architecture - Are you over-engineering?
  2. Measure your actual traffic - Do you need more scale?
  3. Count your team size - Can you support microservices?
  4. Check your budget - Can you afford 10x infrastructure cost?

This month:

  1. If you're a monolith: Add module boundaries
  2. If you're considering splitting: Try vertical scaling + caching first
  3. Benchmark your current performance - Is it actually slow?
  4. Calculate the REAL cost of migration (not just infrastructure!)

This year:

  1. Resist the hype - Choose architecture based on YOUR needs
  2. Document your constraints (team, budget, traffic)
  3. Only split when you have EVIDENCE you need to
  4. Sleep well knowing you made the smart choice! 😊

Resources Worth Your Time 📚

Reading:

Success stories of monoliths:

Real talk: The best architecture is the one your team can actually maintain and iterate on!

Drowning in microservices complexity? Connect with me on LinkedIn and share your architecture war stories!

Want to see my architecture patterns? Check out my GitHub - from monoliths to microservices!

Now go forth and build responsibly! 🏗️✨

P.S. If you're a 3-person startup building microservices, please stop. You're making your life 10x harder for zero benefit. I've been there. It's not worth it! Start simple! 🙏

P.P.S. I once interviewed at a startup that had 18 microservices with 4 developers. They spent 80% of their time fixing inter-service communication issues instead of building features. They shut down 6 months later. Don't be that startup! The best code is the code that ships! 🚀

← Back to all posts